top of page

The Bagel Bakery was founded in 1967 and has become a staple of the community ever since. Everyone knows if you want the best bagels you come to The Bagel Bakery


Originally just open for Summer, The Bagel Bakery has been a part of the community since 1967. From bagels to breakfast sandwiches, baked goods and deli sandwiches. Over the years The Bagel Bakery has expanded to meet it's customers wants. 

Our History

Our bagels are everyone's FAVORITE! We have everything from the traditional plain, sesame and everything to our own creations in blueberry, french toast and asiago bagels. 

Monticello Bagel Bakery

We offer more than just bagels! From double egg breakfast sandwiches to fresh cut deli sandwiches and more. We offer a wide variety of traditional and custom sandwiches. Both cold and hot. 

More than just bagels!

The Bagel Bakery

"We love to see happy customers come in and out of the bagel bakery. It is an experience for us and the customers to order with us to brighten their day. We value the hard work that our employees do day in and day out to help with our success. The purpose of the bagel bakery on a larger scale is to connect the community and bring everyone together as a whole. We form connections with each other that go much further than a customer to employee relationship that give us insight into life. Our customers are like a family to us and nothing could happen without their support. Our mission is to deliver a good quality product like no other, our bagels have a beautiful crust that has a delicious chewy texture that will have you wanting another bagel."

bottom of page